Welcome to Keuka Cottage

A century-old family lake house filled with charm, sunlight, and summer memories.

Welcome

Welcome to our family cottage on Keuka Lake - a cozy summer home that has been in our family since 1923. Built by our great-grandmother, it has been lovingly passed down through four generations.

It’s simple, bright, and full of heart -a place where mornings start slow, towels dry on the deck railing, puzzles take over the porch table, and kids run in and out of the lake until dinner.

We hope you settle in, breathe deep, unplug, and enjoy the lake the way our family has for nearly 100 years.

Getting Here

The address is 322 State Route 54 (East Lake Road), Penn Yan, NY 14527

GPS gets confused between upper/lower East Lake Road so please use the link above!

Checking In & Checking Out

If we’re not there to greet you, the cottage will be open.
You’ll find the key:

  • hanging on the peg between the kitchen & living room, or

  • behind the sailboat decoration on the front door

Check-In

3:00pm 

Check-Out

11:00am

Cottage Details

  • You may park:

    • 2-3 cars at the top of the road

    • 2-3 cars by the shed, down the driveway

    Backing out head-first is easiest because of the curve.

  • You’ll have access to Spectrum cable, SmartTV apps, Netflix, and Roku. Instructions are in the drawer near the TV.

    WiFi Networks:

    • Starkey (main cottage)

    • Starkey-ROB (waterfront room)

    • Password: Oscar5070

  • We provide bed sheets & bath towels for your stay.

    Extra blankets are stored under beds, in the living room trunk, and in the boathouse armoire.

    If you use extra linens, please launder as our cleaners have a tight turnaround. There’s a laundromat in Penn Yan at Lake Street Plaza. Here’s the LINK.

  • Outdoor lights are labeled - please turn them off at night. Flashlights are in the top drawer of the living room bureau.

  • The thermostat is located in the living room, to the right of the French doors.

    Space heaters are in the front bedroom and the room over the boathouse.

    Please turn heaters off and unplugged when not in use.

  • Just off the kitchen, you’ll find the Weber gas grill and a full outdoor dining set ready for family barbecue nights. It’s the ideal setup for burgers, grilled veggies, and “one more hot dog” moments.

    Extra propane tank is in the shed! Just let us know if you change it out!

  • We usually have items like extra toilet paper, paper towels, etc in the shed near the parking. You can check there if anything has run out or just let us know!

Garbage & Recycling

We try to keep things simple up here on the lake. Trash and recycling are picked up early on Tuesday mornings.

When you arrive, you’ll see the large bins up at the top of the road.
After pickup, feel free to wheel them back down and keep them by the shed so they’re easy to access during your stay.

There’s also a recycling bin right outside the porch door - perfect for bottles, cans, and cardboard. When it’s full, just bring it up to the larger blue bin by the shed.

When you’re heading out, please roll both bins back up to the top of the hill so they’re ready for Tuesday morning pickup.

eating & sleeping

  • Front Bedroom

    The front lake-view bedroom has a full-sized bed and its own door, making it the perfect cozy retreat for afternoon naps or early nights after a long lake day. In the cooler months, feel free to plug in the space heater (and unplug it when you’re done). If you like to sleep bundled up, there’s an extra blanket tucked into the bin under the bed waiting for you.

  • Front Bedroom

  • Middle Bedroom

    Our middle bedroom - the cozy purple room - has a full-sized bed and a sliding handmade barn door that gives you privacy while still feeling connected to the heart of the cottage. Extra blankets are in the closet or in the under-bed bins if you like to bundle up.

  • Bunkbed Room

    Our bunkbed room is equal parts cozy and practical - perfect for any age. You’ll find toys, books, and a step stool nearby, making this room feel a little like its own kid-friendly hideaway. When nighttime comes, close the barn door and settle in with your favorite blanket (extras are in the closet or bins under the bed).

  • The Room Over the Boathouse

    This is our magical “room over the boathouse,” perched right above the water. With one full and one twin beds, couch, large screen TV and windows that open to lake breezes, it’s the dream spot for anyone who wants to fall asleep and wake up to the gentle waves of the lake. Extra blankets are in the armoire, and there’s both a heater and AC to keep you comfy - just unplug them when not in use. It’s cozy, quiet, and feels like your own little lakeside hideout - especially popular with teens. *You do have to walk outside and up to the main cottage to use the bathroom.

  • Our Kitchen

    Our kitchen is cozy, simple, and stocked with everything you need to make cottage meals feel effortless. You’ll find all the basics - pots, pans, dishes, utensils - plus a Cuisinart, Nutribullet, and blender for smoothies, sauces, or whatever you’re inspired to whip up after a long day on the lake.

    Pantry staples like oil, spices, foil, and wraps are there for you to use. Just let us know if you use the last of anything!

  • Our Living Room

    You’ll find the middle and bunk bedrooms off this living room. Feel free to stream your favorite shows; we’ve stocked Roku and Netflix and the WiFi password is ready to go. Whether you’re winding down after a day in the sun or gathering for a movie night, this room is where everyone naturally lands (or naps).

  • Our Living Room

  • The Porch

    If the cottage had a soul, it would be the porch. It’s where mornings start with coffee in pajamas and days stretch into games, crafts, sunset chats, and late-night stories when the lake goes quiet. Keep an eye out for George the woodchuck, who occasionally wanders by. It’s the perfect place to read, snack, laugh, and lose track of time - just as lake days should be.

get outside

From spontaneous games of tag on the grass to long, lazy afternoons floating in the lake, these are the moments that make Keuka feel like a world of its own.

Front Patio & Lawn

The front patio faces the cottage’s big sloping lawn - a great spot for lawn games, picnic blankets, or simply watching the occasional neighbor stroll by. Lawn games and outdoor toys are stored in the shed, so feel free to pull out cornhole, bocce, or whatever inspires a little friendly competition.

And yes, you’ll catch some amazing rainbows from this spot!

Upper Lakeview Deck

Perched up in the trees with a postcard-worthy view of Keuka Lake, the upper deck is where hours magically disappear. Whether you’re sipping morning coffee, sharing a slow lunch, or settling in for golden-hour lounging, this space is made for unwinding. Comfortable cushioned seating, a large outdoor dining table, and dappled sunlight through the branches make it the perfect hangout spot from sunrise to sunset.

Whether you’re seeking quiet reflection or joyful interruption, the dock is where it all happens. Stretch out with a book, cast a fishing line, jump in for a swim - or, like Gio, confidently insert yourself between cousins mid-relaxation. As the sun sets and the lake glows, you’ll understand why everyone eventually falls silent… at least until someone cannonballs in.

Bringing your own boat? You’re welcome to tie up on the left side of the dock - it can comfortably accommodate boats up to 21 feet.

Lakefront Dock

Boating & Kayaking & S’mores

We provide kayaks, paddles, a paddleboard, tubes, a pump for inflatables, and life vests & water shoes in a range of sizes. They are all stored in the boathouse just off the deck with easy access to the lake. Before using the water shoes, we recommend giving them a quick rinse - occasionally little friends like to make cozy homes in unexpected places!

For kayaks and paddleboards, a life vest and a whistle or other sound-producing device is required and very helpful for signaling on the water - we’ve provided whistles near the boathouse for your use.

The lakefront fire pit sits near the water ready for roasting marshmallows and long chats. Please keep it near the water for safety!

Fishing On & Off the Dock

Fishing off the dock is a favorite here - perfect for kids, beginners, and anyone chasing that “just one more cast” moment. The lake is home to bass and bluegill and perch and pumpkinseeds and anything in between, making it a fun spot to reel something in.

A classic dock catch often turns into a photo op. Pro tip: please handle in a fish-friendly way like Uncle PJ - Gio’s fish manners are still loading.

Bring your poles, enjoy the quiet (or the excitement), and don’t forget to snap a photo so we can keep the photo gallery up to date!

Over 16? Check out this LINK for details on fish licenses.

Departure Checklist:

Inside The Cottage

  • Used sheets & towels: Place all used linens inside pillowcases in the living room or in a laundry basket. If towels are wet, please hang them on hooks in the bathroom or bunk room.

  • Kitchen: Remove all food from the refrigerator (condiments are fine to leave). Wipe down shelves if anything spilled.

  • Keys: Return the single key behind the sailboat. Any extra keys can be left on the peg in the kitchen.

We hope you had a wonderful stay at our family cottage. Because we often have quick turnovers between guests, these few steps make a big difference and are deeply appreciated.

  • Supplies: If you used the last of anything (ex: toilet paper, paper towels, propane), let us know.

Outside The Cottage

  • Grill: If you used the grill, please wipe it down after your final use

  • Propane: If you used the last of a propane tank, just let us know so we can replace it

  • Garbage & Recycling: Please roll all garbage and recycling bins back up to the top of the hill/road where you found them (if you are physically unable, it’s no problem, just let us know!)

If You Brought a Pet

  • Vacuum: Vacuum carpets if needed (vacuum is in the bunkbed room closet)

  • Check Around Inside & Outside of Cottage: Please check corners, rugs, and furniture for pet hair and other “deposits”!

General

    • High Season (late June–Labor Day): $1,750/week 

    • Low Season (Memorial Day–late June, Labor Day–Columbus Day): $1,540/week or $220/night (5-night minimum)

    • Cleaning Fee: $200 per stay (unchanged; additional cleanings available for extended stays at $200 each)

    • Elfe Cimicata | M. 917-324-4287 | elfecimicata@gmail.com

    • Susie Cimicata | M. 585-747-3370

    • Paul Cimicata | M. 407-414-8845‬

  • We accept multiple forms of payment to keep things simple and flexible, including paypal, venmo & zelle (click gon buttons below). If you need to use a different method or have questions about payment options, just email us and we’ll figure out the best solution together.

    For privacy and security reasons, we do not accept checks by mail unless arranged in advance

    • Do you allow pets? We love our pets! We ask the same of our furry friends as we do of our guests. Please pick up after yourself! We also prefer pets stay off the furniture. Please see the departure checklist for additional pet-related check-out items.

    • Where are extra supplies? If you are not able to find something, please look in the shed near the parking area. We usually have extra toilet paper, paper towels, bathroom items stored there.

If you have any questions during your stay - or if something needs attention - please don’t hesitate to reach out. We’re happy to help and want your time at the cottage to be easy and relaxing.

ZELLE
VENMO
PAYPAL
EMAIL US!

A Few Local Favorites

drinking

Local breweries, wineries, and easy places to grab a drink.

Click the image → open the map → turn on the “Drinking” layer

eating

Ice cream stops, casual meals, and favorite local bites.

Click the image → open the map → turn on the “Eating” layer

moving

Trails, hikes, biking routes, and places to stretch your legs.

Click the image → open the map → turn on the “Moving” layer

wandering

Small towns, shops, antiques, and “let’s just stroll” spots.

Click the image → open the map → turn on the “Wandering” layer